By 1858 Methodists in the area had established a place for worship, Saint Paul's Methodist Church, with a cemetery on the site beside it. The early Presbyterians also held services in the church. In 1874 the Wesleyan Methodists, Primitive Methodists, Methodist New Connection and Methodist Episcopal all joined to form one Methodist Church. In 1928 at the time of Church Union, the name was changed to Saint Paul's United Church. In 1970 the church was sold to the Milverton Conservative Mennonite Congregation but care of the adjoining cemetery remained in the hands of the United Church. In 1978 the surviving tombstones were moved to the rear of the plot and placed in an orderly row for easier maintenance.